Switch Flipping
from 1.26.04
a response in part to Chris's essay
Hy called in the evening, surprise surprise, and we had a great conversation about writing. Hy has a lot of interests and skills that I do not have. He's created a map of his fantasy world, naming mountain ranges and bodies of water, drawing the continental shapes, populating the world with different races, designing religions for the different peoples, writing a history of the different peoples, and more. Even within the context of a genre, where stories and plots are already laid out for him, there is still a lot of impressive value in the very fact that he can create all the details of an entire world. That is a skill that I do not possess. His take on my writing is that I have more political and humanitarian interests, and that I write for myself, so I don't have to worry about creating characters (and their backstories) whose purpose is to entertain. As I told him, I do want to be entertaining, but through my sense of humor, not by creating soap opera type characters.
He was excited to tell me that he had a breakthrough in his guitar playing, and I told him how exciting that can be when a switch flips, to use my metaphor. He knew that you can write a song with only two chords, previously, but it finally clicked in his brain and that concept now seems to have a reality that it didn't have before, and he is now practicing with a newfound confidence and ability. This is the same thing that happened to me with my guitar playing and, just this past summer, with my singing. It is exciting, as if a new area of the brain begins to be utilized.
With writing, I am still waiting for a switch to flip. I told Hy how it can be discouraging, waiting for that to happen. For example I've tried reporting, hit a wall, and stopped. Nonfiction book writing, with the guide to the comic book business: same thing. Short stories, like two nights ago, when I tried to start one about a straight-edge girl in rural Kentucky who is the only person in her high school class. Unlike him, I found myself unable to take enough interest in the character to create a back story for her, to introduce other characters to provide a conflict, or to even think of a reason why she might be the sole person in her high school class. Salinger had Holden Caulfield. I have not yet created a character who takes over the story and directs it, who begins to speak on his own or make her own decisions, where I become a simple transcriber of the story.
On the other hand, Nabokov said anyone whose characters direct themselves can't call himself a writer.
I also told him about my bit of self-revelation, where I now know that writing is a means to keep me mentally healthy and stave off depression and listlessness. Again, that's reason enough to continue doing it. Hy told me to try not to put expectations on myself. To simply start where my interests lie, begin writing, and see where it takes me. That is often what he does: he starts a conversation between two characters without knowing where it's going, and they begin to reveal their personalities as the conversation grows.
It could be that, simply, I'm not that kind of writer, the kind who creates unique characters with all their backstory and hopes and dreams and complex personalities. That I must keep trying and experimenting with stories until I find the one that clicks with me. One promising story style for me is Vonnegut-style essay stories, letters to a government agency explaining something that happened from the narrator's point of view. Keep practicing until the switch flips. Remember: with guitar playing and with singing I had to do it over and over and over for YEARS until certain switches flipped. Only then, with continued practice, will the switch flip. It will not flip by sitting around and thinking about it.
It could also be that practice will result in a switch flip that turns me into a fine character composer, where I enjoy delineating their backstories, creating their personalities, and then pitting them against one another so that they take over and direct which way the story goes. Who can say.